It's Time to Shift the Narrative

From population control and falling fertility to family planning and contraception

The Story so Far

Media narratives on family planning are restricted to either overpopulation or falling fertility rates. That’s concerning. You can read about it on our Instagram here.

Media coverage on population growth in India often veers towards simplistic narratives, frequently focusing on overpopulation concerns rather than exploring the complexities of family planning and reproductive health. This narrow perspective not only overlooks the multifaceted nature of the issue but also perpetuates harmful stereotypes and biases, especially on women.

Stigmatization of Family Planning and Contraception

When media narratives focus on overpopulation or alarmist views on falling fertility rates, it leads to stigmatization. Families think they are in the wrong, and then contraception and family planning seem like issues imposed by authorities and NGOs, rather than empowering tools for reproductive autonomy.

Discrimination Against Women and Families

Media narratives that emphasize overpopulation often indirectly blame families for having “too many” children, which disproportionately affects lower-income communities where birth rates tend to be higher. This increases discrimination against marginalized communities, reinforcing harmful stereotypes and encouraging policies that prioritize control over family planning empowerment.

Misleading Priorities in Public Perception and Policy

By focusing primarily on numbers—population statistics or declining total fertility rates (TFR)—media coverage often diverts attention from the underlying causes of these trends, such as gaps in healthcare access, education, and socio-economic support. As a result, policies may emphasize population control over expanding access to healthcare and education, which are essential for informed family planning.

Limited Access to Contraceptive Services

When discussions around family planning are limited to managing population size, contraceptive services may be viewed narrowly as population control tools rather than essential healthcare services. This perspective can restrict funding and access to a full range of contraceptive options, limiting people’s choices and discouraging comprehensive family planning services.

Impact on Women’s Health, Rights, and Autonomy

a. Increased Health Risks for Women

Women are less likely to receive information on how contraception can prevent high-risk pregnancies, maternal mortality, and unsafe abortions.

b. Erosion of Reproductive Rights and Autonomy

Focusing on population control rather than individual needs diminishes the role of women’s choice and autonomy in family planning decisions. Women may feel pressured to adhere to societal expectations rather than make informed choices based on their health, family goals, or personal needs.

c. Missed Opportunities for Economic and Social Empowerment

Family planning gives women greater control over their reproductive lives, allowing them to pursue education and career opportunities. When the media focuses on TFRs and overpopulation instead of these empowerment aspects, it minimizes the role family planning can play in advancing gender equality and economic independence for women.

What Should the Media Do?

a. Highlight Contraception as a Health and Empowerment Tool

Media should frame family planning not as a tool for controlling the population but as a fundamental health service that protects women’s health, reduces maternal mortality, and allows women and couples to make informed choices.

b. Focus on Reproductive Autonomy and Informed Choice

Media narratives should emphasize the role of family planning in enhancing women’s autonomy and agency over their own lives. Journalists can incorporate personal stories that highlight how family planning improves lives, offering real-life perspectives that underscore the value of informed choice.

c. Address Barriers to Access and Affordability

Coverage should stress contraception’s role in preventing unintended pregnancies and supporting long-term health and well-being of women. The media should cover gaps in healthcare infrastructure, cost issues, and geographical disparities, thereby promoting policies that address these challenges.

d. Use Evidence-Based Reporting and Data-Driven Insights

Media coverage should rely on credible data from sources like the National Family Health Survey (NFHS), the World Health Organization (WHO), and the United Nations to present the health and social benefits of contraception. Evidence-based reporting can shift the focus from fears of population decline to the practical, positive impacts of accessible family planning.

e. Educate and Inform on Diverse Contraceptive Options

The media should educate the public on the variety of contraceptive options available, including the pros and cons of each. Providing balanced information on choices ranging from hormonal contraception to IUDs and other modern methods allows people to make decisions best suited to their needs.

f. Promote Positive Messaging Around Family Planning

Instead of focusing on limitations or societal pressures, the media can promote positive messaging around the benefits of family planning, both for individual health and for broader societal development. Stories highlighting family planning success cases can create a supportive environment for open discussions on contraception.

Some Data Points to Consider

Maternal Mortality Reduction: A 2012 Lancet study says improving family planning services could prevent around 35% of maternal deaths in India, as it lowers the number of unintended pregnancies and high-risk births.

Reduction in Adolescent Pregnancy: The National Family Health Survey (NFHS-5) found that 7.9% of women aged 15-19 had begun childbearing. Access to contraception and education about family planning could help reduce these figures and improve outcomes.

Child Health Benefits: Data from NFHS-5 shows that birth intervals of fewer than 24 months are linked to a higher risk of neonatal mortality, and wider access to family planning could save many lives.

Please let us know what you think of this newsletter. If you disagree with our analysis, please write back. If we have missed out on something or made wrong claims, please let us know.

Do write to us with any feedback, positive or critical. Like all new initiatives, there is a learning curve. We are especially cognizant that you have chosen to give us your valuable time from the millions of content options out there. Thank you!

Please reply to this email if you want us to cover any topic in particular. Definitely write to us if you want to cover a topic for us.

If you like what we do, please forward this newsletter to your friends and people you love.

If someone you love has sent you this newsletter, please click here and sign up for the newsletter and check out our Instagram page for more.

So long!

Team Reading Room